Bending fatigue failure in gear tooth ijert journal. It results in progressive damage to gear teeth and ultimately leads to the complete failure of the gear. Knowing the various modes by which the gears tend to fail helps one to identify the problem at an initial stage and rectify the problem related to the gear. At the same time, where the driven tooth addendum surface is in compression, fatigue can not occur. Ideally, the analyst should visit the site and inspect failed components as soon after failure as possible. Fortunately, gear couplings often provide signature failure modes that. It also contains an indepth discussion of the gear tooth failure. This fact has demanded that new fatigue tests for gear materials be carried out and the fatigue resistance behavior with a high number of load cycles be analyzed.
Superfinish, coat, or smooth bearing rings or elements. In the spur gears the tooth surface of the gears is exactly. In order to avoid this problem we have to design the geometrical features of the gears very properly. Gear tooth failure problem resolution msi was contracted by the oem to perform testing and analysis to determine the root cause of gear tooth failures on an aeroderivative gas turbine power generation drivetrain. Pdf dynamic analysis of a planetary gear failure caused by. Contact stress and shear stress analysis of spur gear.
Failure in a gear train can in many cases be prevented. This gear have tooth breakage problem on one tooth as shown. Any component within the machine is going to wear down from constant use. Parts analysis process spur gears 90 roller bearings 93 main shaft washer 95 main shaft gear float clearance. Jgma 7001011990 terms of gear tooth failure modes jis b 0160. Interference analysis the smallest number of teeth on a spur pinion and gear, onetoone gear ratio, which can exist without interference is np. Contact stress analyses for spur and helical gears are performed between two gear teeth at different contact positions during rotation.
Gearbox typical failure modes, detection and mitigation. Gears and how their world is changing by neville w. Common gear failures gear solutions magazine your resource. These craters are formed due to the high amount of compressive contact stresses in the gear surface occurring during transmission of the torque or in simple terms due to compressive fatigue on the gear tooth surface.
Scuffing often happens to new gears when tooth surfaces are not yet well runin. These three modes will be investigated further, and the importance of using the right material to. The failure investigation of a gear should be planned carefully to preserve evidence. Pdf failure analysis of a helical gear researchgate. When an issue with the gears takes place, it is necessary to determine if a rebuild, upgrade or replacement is the best choice available. Focus of the work stress analysis such as prediction of contact stress and. Gear failure analysis a textbook for the gear failure analyst. Stress analysis focuses on the determination of the regions of stress concentration where failure or fracture may be initiated. Contact stress analysis for a pair of mating gears. Grindhonepolish gear teeth superfinish, coat, or smooth bearing rings or elements avoid shotpeened flanks make hardest gear bearing element as smooth as possible make pinion 2 hrc points harder than gear use oil with high micropitting resistance keep lubricant cool, clean, and dry use highviscosity lubricant. Bending fatigue failure is the result of cyclic bending stress at the tooth root. Often a large number of factors, frequently interrelated, must be understood to determine the cause of the original, or primary, failure.
Failure analysis in study of any failure, the analyst must consider a broad spectrum of possibilities or reasons for the occurrence. The failure conditions can determine when and how to conduct an analysis. Finally, despite all of our efforts to avoid coupling failure, our installations and our personnel need be able to adequately respond to failure modes which experience shows are credible. Sokovic 2010 failure analysis of the pinion from the drive of a cement mill, tehnicka dijagnostika no. Sep 26, 2016 machinery breakdowns are often the result of gear failure. This can be prevented by proper selection of the lubricant and monitoring of the gearbox temperature at equal. Cause of failure may range from excessive wear to catastrophic breakage. The analysis of bending stress in gear tooth was done by mr. To compare the static transmission errors of slandered and modified profile of the gear teeth. Evaluating gear tooth wear and being able to root cause and address coupling failure are both critical to ensuring maximum reliability and uptime for a given mechanical power transmission system. The cross section was etched as shown in figure 6 and grinding abuse was observed on both sides of the tooth. This paper gives a finite element model for investigation of the stresses in the tooth during the meshing of gears for material steel 15ni2cr1mo28. This type pitting can develop within a relatively short time, reach.
Imagine driving a car with a broken gear in its gearbox. Therefore, it is not easy to figure out solutions to causes. Wind turbine gearbox condition monitoring round robin. To generate the profile of spur gear teeth and calculate of gear bending stress using lewis equation and hence check the feasibility of modified gear profile. When a failure arises from this cause there are often other adjacent teeth showing cracks at an earlier stage of development. Surface contact fatigue failure of a case hardened pinion shaft. So we directly find the deflection of the parabolic teeth with minor errors with actual deflection 2, 3. Be careful not to contaminate the gearbox during cleaning or during the removal of the port cover. Dynamic analysis of a planetary gear failure caused by tooth.
Complete this step before disassembling gearbox components for inspection. While on the righthand side, the spiral bevel gear was loaded on the concave face of the gear teeth. Wilfred lewis in his paper, the investigation of the strength of gear tooth submitted at the engineers club of philadelphia in 1892. Pdf involute gear tooth stresses analysis using finite. This type of failure is also characterized by a burning smell of the lubricating oil during running and also development of burn marks on the contact teeth surface. In both cases, we are interested in the tooth load, which we got from the torque, t. Coupling credible failure modes and owner options to intervene. Failure analysis in study of any failure, the analyst must consider a broad spectrum of. Various vibration based analysis technique in general, each type of failure leaves characteristic clues on gear. Gears of this type satisfy all the requirements for smonthvaccurete and continuous motion. Under these variable loads a tooth breakage, which most often results in a total gear failure, must be take into account during the stages of gear design or load capacity calculation. Gear tooth contact patterns to observe the condition of the gears, shafts, and bearings, clean the inspection port cover and the immediate area around it, and then remove the cover. National renewable energy laboratory national wind technology center.
Included are photo graphs of actual failures, along with probable cause and the most effective remedies. Tooth pitting and cracking are frequently encountered failure modes. Gear has failed when it can no longer efficiently do the job for which it was designed. As the gears counterrotate, the separating gear teeth create a vacuum, drawing oil into the inlet.
The cause of gear failure can stem from many issues, but the most common is due to wear. Pitting is the formation of craters on the gear tooth surface. They can be identified by ripples on the contacting gear tooth surface. Derivation of deflection for gear tooth using castiglianos theorem lewis has assumed parabola in the gear tooth. Hydraulic gear pump and motor failure analysis and repair. Wear debris in the oil may help indicate failure modes that occurred in the gearbox and reveal contaminants that contributed to the failure. Damage to gears is basically categorized by two types. As before, analysing and diagnosing gear failures is all about recognising the visual signs associated with typical failure modes. Contact failure in gears is currently predicted by comparing the calculated hertz contact stress to. Gears with involute tooth profile are very flexible in both geometric modificati on and center distance variation.
Fortunately, gear couplings often provide signature failure modes that can be quickly identified and diagnosed. Analysis of spur gear using ansys the two dimensional models fatigue or yielding of a gear tooth due to excessive bending stress is two important gear design considerations. This paper presents a contact stress analysis for a pair of mating gears during rotation. Tooth bending fatigue failure in gears 221 several times. Geartech, bearing failure analysis a textbook for the bearing failure analyst. The root cause of the fretting corrosion was parking of the wind turbine. Despite these advantages, the severe conditions under which such gears are typically used may lead to failure. Relationship between the involute elements determination of base tooth thickness from a known thickness and viceversa. The operating surfaces of gear teeth suffer pitting when subject to excessive contact stress. Investigation of contact stress in spur gear using lewis equation and finite element method ashish v kadu1 and sanjay s deshmukh1 corresponding author. For example, after a disc pack diaphragm fracor s or tureafter severe gear tooth wear, our vibration interlock set points and.
Gearbox reliability collaborative gearbox 1 failure analysis report. Formulas for gear calculation external gears contents. Static analysis of bending stresses on spur gear tooth. The bending and surface stresses of gear tooth are major factor for failure of gear. The appearance of the various distress and failure modes can differ between gears that have through hardened teeth and. Spur gear tooth stress analysis and stress reduction. Gears are more vulnerable to scuffing when they are new and their tooth surfaces have not yet been smooth end by runin. Tooth contact stress analysis one of the main gear tooth failure is pitting which is a surface fatigue failure due to many repetition of high contact stresses occurring in the gear tooth surface while a pair of teeth is transmitting power. Continuing our series on articles on how to diagnose different machinery failures, this page looks at the failure of gears. Contact stress and shear stress analysis of spur gear using. Pdf the failure investigation of a gear should be planned carefully to preserve evidence.
It is best to shut down a failing gearbox as soon as possible to limit damage. Fatigue failure pitting in the contact surface of a gear tooth. Analysis will be presented in the later portion of this paper to bound the crack propagation path. Dedendum pitting results when loads are at or close to maximum 108010 rexnord industries, llc, gear group failure analysis. Fretting corrosion is deterioration of contacting gear tooth surfaces caused by minute vibratory motion. Pitting is a surface fatigue failure due to repetitions of high contact stresses.
Dynamic analysis of a planetary gear failure caused by tooth pitting and cracking. Serious progressive pitting, associated with continuous overloading will become steadily worse and probably lead eventually to tooth breakage see later example. These three modes will be investigated further, and the importance of using the right material to avoid these failures will be highlighted. Cylindrical spur gears with standard profile cylindrical spur gears with corrected profile without centre distance variation with centre distance variation. The number of teeth for spur gears is given by where k 1f fll1 for fulld tht th08f tbt th d ldepth teeth, 0. Estimating gear fatigue life gear solutions magazine. This is a major cause of gear failure accounting for nearly 60% of the gear failures. Initial pitting is caused by local areas of high stress due to uneven surfaces on the gear tooth.
Smart size is used the number of elements near the roots of the teeth are automatically are much greater than in other places. Drive and coast sides of hypoid ring gear teeth etching surface fatigue 9 extreme pressure ep additives. Contact stress analysis of spur gear ijert journal. The failure starts as a crack which is usually at the root of the tooth and proceeds across the base of the tooth until the complete tooth breaks away from the gear. The gear tooth deflection, as a consequence of normal force acting at the outer single engagement point of meshing gears, is numerically studied using linear elastic and marlow hyperelastic constitutive model.
Gearbox typical failure modes, detection and mitigation methods. The righthand side gearbox was subsequently transferred to the lefthand side and failure of a spiral bevel gear set occurred after 2 weeks 5. Note the deep ridges, and the ends of the gear teeth, which were not subjected to the abrasive action. Strength rating how much hp can be transmitted before a shaft or gear fails due to. Failure analysis on rear gearbox output gear of helicopter icas. Pdf dynamic analysis of a planetary gear failure caused. Geartech, gear failure analysis a textbook for the gear failure analyst. Description of the failure figure 2 shows a pinion tooth subjected to failure analysis due to the extensive deterioration it suffered during inservice conditions. Figure 5 shows the crack trajectory to be inward from the tooth surface.
Plant engineering eight common causes of gear failure. These results might explain abrasion on gear teeth and bearing surfaces. They used the ansys for stress analysis to find out the cause of failure of the gear and improve the life of the gear they found the reason of failure the gear is wear at gear tooth edge. However, by introducing stress relieving features to the gear, the points of stress concentration can be decreased which enhances life of gear. This research utilizes the finite element method to investigate the variation of contact stress along the line of contact. In addition, there are other specific damages, such as the deterioration of plastic material, the rim or web breakages. If it occurs with gears, it can have a detrimental impact on the equipments operation. Both bearing and gear failures are concentrated in the parallel section.
Stress analysis has been a key area of research to minimize failure and optimize desi gn. Sort by date 1 the gear gods help those that help themselves januaryfebruary 20 gear train is a new gear technology section focusing on training and education in the gear industry. Jan 30, 2015 evaluating gear tooth wear and being able to root cause and address coupling failure are both critical to ensuring maximum reliability and uptime for a given mechanical power transmission system. Design and analysis of spur gear iaeme publication. If practical, record tooth contact patterns under either loaded or unloaded conditions. In an analysis of more than 1,500 gear failure studies, the three most common failure modes were tooth bending fatigue, tooth bending impact, and abrasive tooth wear 4. Therefore, scuffing is the most immediate failure mode that must be dealt with. Stress analysis for gear teeth is regarded as a limiting factor for designers. Oil is picked up by each tooth and carried around the. On the dedendum of the driving tooth, as the driven tooth slides downward, the driving tooth surface is subjected to tension, surface fatigue results, and the tooth wears. Gearbox typical failure modes, detection, and mitigation.
Of these, one of the most common causes of gear failure is tooth bending fatigue. Planetary gears are widely used in aeronautic and industrial applications that require compactness and high torquetoweight ratios. The way in which mating gear teeth contact indicates how well they are aligned figure 1. The gear had failed in service by one of its teeth having broken off the gear body. By the help of this paper we can know about different types of failure detection and.
This fatigue failure of the tooth decides the reliability of the gear. Surface contact fatigue failure of a case hardened pinion. Any failure to the gear system leads to the total system failure. However, because gear failures provide valuable data that may help prevent. The comprehensive computational analysis of gear tooth deflection of spur polymer gears is presented in this paper. Gears can fail in many different ways, and except for an increase in noise level and vibration, there is often no indication of difficulty until total failure occurs. Figure 1 shows a schematic of the intermediate gear set evaluated in this case study. Most gears had some teeth corrosion, with mild to severe fretting. Tooth bending fatigue and surface contact fatigue are two of the most common modes of fatigue failure for gears. The main factors that cause the failure of gears are the bending stress an d contact stress of the gear tooth. In the current analysis of spur gear we follow the lewis assumptions and equation.
Failures of gears1 failure analysis and prevention. Analysis of failed traction motor pinion gear page 1 of 19 analysis of failed locomotive train motor pinion gear 1. Spectrometric analysis can uncover contamination via environmental dust by showing high concentrations of silicon and aluminum. Even today, the lewis equation is considered as the basic equation in the design of gears 1. Gear damage are defined by the following standards. The defects are modeled and discussed for a planetary gear set. How to diagnose gear failures neale consulting engineers. Stresses on spur gear teeth the two primary failure modes for gears are. Figure 2 shows a pinion tooth subjected to failure analysis due to the extensive deterioration it suffered during inservice conditions.
627 480 1134 1264 59 953 159 303 956 815 1211 987 445 415 665 674 566 1101 788 325 917 749 1512 1356 922 42 1057 62 120 517 165 481 233 927 1383 880 42 509